Here are the best and worst Space Movies, according to NASA astronaut

Garrett Reisman, a former NASA astronaut, gave his sincere opinion about a few of the hottest house films to come out of Hollywood. Keep studying, your favorite may simply be on his ‘worst-rated record.

It’s an exquisite time to be alive. We’re dwelling in a time in our evolution the place we are able to ship robots to different planets for exploration. But it’s okay to bask in some defective science fiction from time to time.

NASA-approved house films

Apollo 13 (based mostly on an actual NASA mission)

Apollo 13 is at the prime of Reisman’s record, scoring a cool 10/10 score. The occasions of the film actually occurred, and the cast did an excellent job of bringing it to life. Reisman says Apollo 13 is “the gold standard”.

“They got it right more than probably any other movie ever made about space. This movie is the closest thing to being a documentary without actually taking cameras up and filming it in space”.

He defined that the cast of Apollo 13 – starring Tom Hanks, Bill Paxton, Kevin Bacon and Ed Harris – even used precise dialogue from the actual mission, based mostly on NASA’s recordings of the transmissions.

“They had transcripts of what actually happened during the real Apollo 13 […] And so what you see in that movie is 100% real”.

Garrett Reisman, a former NASA astronaut.

2001: A Space Odyssey

In the second spot is 2001: A Spacey Odyssey. With a Reisman Rating of 9/10, it’s one among his “all-time favorite space films”. He praises the movie’s realism, regardless of it being filmed earlier than Apollo 11, or earlier than people landed on the moon.

“And the science in the movie holds up tremendously well. The one thing that’s missing there, and in the opening scene there, is the atmosphere. You just see the blue Earth and then suddenly the black space.”

Reisman explains that, in actuality, “there’s a thin blue line that seperates the sunlit Earth from the blackness of space”. He additionally lauded the movies depicting of making artifcial gravity.

The lack of gravity in areas causes “all kind of funky and not-so-good things to happen” to human our bodies, so astronauts combat it by understanding for 2 hours a day. But, hey, what if we are able to create synthetic gravity, Reisman asks.

“By spinning [the space station] like that, you can create centrifugal force that acts and feels like artificial gravity. If you’re creating artificial gravity with a small radius, you can handle that spinning for a couple minutes”.


Interstellar is his third favorite with a score of 8/10, which Reisman’s describes as “pretty trippy”. Nobody is aware of what occurs inside as a result of nothing ever escapes a black gap.

“If a person went inside a black hole, what would it really be like? Who knows? But you do see the light bending in there, and it is true that light will bend when it’s exposed to very strong gravitational fields. A lot of the stuff that they did in this movie, they tried to be as realistic as possible”.

However, Reisman, has an issue with the “bookshelf tesseract thing”. You may familar with the scene. Some superior civilization created this tesseract for speaking with folks in different dimensions.

He feels that the scene might need been “overly complicated. But other than that, “they got a lot of stuff right, especially about the relativistic effects in the movie”.

“If you’re a super-advanced alien intelligence that can build a bookshelf tesseract thing to go across dimensions, why can’t you put in a phone? Or at least put in, like, a whiteboard, right? With a dry-erase marker that you could just spell, like, “Hey! Stay away from the black hole!”

Star Trek Into Darkness

Star Trek Into Darkness acquired a score of seven out of 10 from Reisman, and he had a cool story about the degrading gravity plate and determined not to “knock ‘Star Trek’ down for it’s depiction of artificial gravity”.

Reisman explains that astronauts on the house station can select to discuss to celebrities “as kind of a morale boost”. Reisman wished to discuss to Ron Moore and David Eick, the creators of Battlestar Galactica.

“We had this video teleconference, and I said to them, ‘You know, you did the same thing. You come up with this artificial gravity on Galactica. Everybody’s just walking around like they’re on Earth, but you’re out in the middle of space. Where’s the gravity coming from? Why do you have to do that? Like, why would you take away one of the coolest things about being up here, the ability to fly?’ And Ron Moore said to me, he said, ‘Garrett… You have any idea how expensive those special effects are and all those stunts?’ So I’m not gonna knock “Star Trek” down”.

Now for the worst….

The worst house films

The Martian (not based mostly on an actual NASA mission)

Reisman provides The Martian a 3 out of 10. I’m not going to lie, this one harm me personally. While the movie has been praised for “very real depiction of science”, it nonetheless will get some stuff horribly fallacious.

“This whole idea about puncturing your glove to fly like Iron Man and be rescued by your spaceship. Yeah, not so much. We have a jet pack that we wear when we do spacewalks on the space station”.

While the Iron Man scene is “bogus, big-time bogus” according to Reisman, he says the “the rest of the movie was up, like, a nine; the rest of the movie was really, really good”.

Guardians of the Galalxy

Look, I do know Guardians will not be meant to be “real”, however this harm me too. While the science was a bit off, Reisman does say that any film with a speaking raccoon is OK in his ebook. He has a giant concern with Starman’s swimsuit.

“It’s great that he’s got this mask on so he can breathe in space, but what about the rest of his body? The rest of your body is gonna be in really, really bad shape. The fluids inside your tissues are gonna vaporise, and so basically, your blood is gonna boil, all the water in your tissue is gonna turn into gas. He takes off his helmet to try to save his friend there, somehow holds his breath”.

Reisman explains {that a} human “can survive for very brief periods of time while exposed to a vacuum, it has been done. However, said human is going to be worried about “barotrauma”.

“So, what that means is that there’s gas inside your body, in your lungs, in your sinuses, and that’s gonna start expanding once you get exposed to a vacuum, ’cause now, instead of having the outside air pressure to work against, now there’s nothing out here. It’s gonna want to blow up like a balloon. Then you worry about decompression sickness, where all the nitrogen comes out of the solution in your blood, what scuba divers can get when they spend too much time at depth and come up too quickly. They call it “the bends” ’trigger you bend over in ache at all of your joints the place the bubbles build up. So all that may occur to Star-Lord even earlier than he takes off his masks”.

It appears that Rocket is the movie’s saving grace. Reisman concludes: “Having said that, did I mention that this movie has a talking raccoon? You’re worried about the helmet? I mean, it’s got a talking raccoon”.

He appears to actually like the racoon. Guardians of the Galaxy will get a 2.5 out of 10.


Reisman stated he heard house particles knock into the house station throughout his time there. The means during which the movie depicts house particles will not be correct, as a result of you’ll be able to “see it coming in the movie”.

“They see this, like, a cloud of debris coming from thousands of kilometres away. That’s bogus, OK? This stuff is travelling an order of magnitude like 10 times faster than a rifle bullet. You can’t look at a shooting range and see a rifle bullet flying around from thousands of kilometres away. You’re not gonna see this stuff coming”.

He additionally says it’s “completely unrealistic” that George Clooney is flying on by, and Sandra Bullock reaches and grabs his tether and grabs onto him. That can be exhausting, as a result of, along with his momentum, the would “carry her away”.

Gravity will get a Reisman score of two out of 10, making it the worst of the worst, rivalled solely be Spaceballs.

Also learn: NASA’s Perseverance rover officially ready to search for life on Mars

Back to top button